?

Log in

No account? Create an account
 
 
29 December 2008 @ 08:11 pm
No Reason  
I might as well go on the record as not being a particularly big fan of Neal Stephenson. A lot of people who know me know that. I just don't like his voice.

Okay, more specifically -- the real reason I don't particularly like his books is that he's clever and he knows it. And, well, he is clever -- when he pulls it off, it works, and it's really entertaining. But when he doesn't, it's like he's just saying "look! See how clever I am?" -- and without a sufficient dosage of clever to back it up, it's just annoying.

When he really goes off the rails -- which is a lot -- it's completely over the top, like he's screaming out "look at how f*cking clever I am!" and it's really, really annoying.

I've been told that Snowcrash was as much a parody of cyberpunk as anything, although I hated that particular version of cyberpunk enough to hate a parody of it, too... But he does the same d*mned thing in Cryptonomicon, and what's he parodying there? Himself?

It makes a book that's really quite strong in a lot of ways pretty annoying to read at times.

Still, it's a lot better than anything else of his I ever tried to read (or actually finished -- I'm almost done with the Cryptonomicon now), and I'd probably actually recommend it fairly strongly, annoyances and all. It's aggravating as much because he's really close -- where reading something by somebody who's just pure crap doesn't push any buttons, you just dump it and move on.

Especially for anybody who still reads like a teenager does -- I would have liked it a lot more back in the days when I could still stomach everything Heinlein wrote.
 
 
In the mood: busy
 
 
 
thjazithjazi on January 13th, 2009 12:12 pm (UTC)
stomaching Heinlein
The only book of his that I could ever stand was Starship Troopers or if the name is different that book. Been a long while since I read it, but now I have to dig for it. I also liked the pastiche of the book by Steakley? called Armor.. who also wrote a book about vampires in North Dallas.

So, would you recommend that I acquire a copy of Neal's Snowcrash? It was/is next on my list of acquisitions... I came back to cyberpunk last fall after a decade long hiatus (was sick and read hardwired again...).


Douglas Triggs: lodestardoubt72 on January 14th, 2009 01:44 am (UTC)
Re: stomaching Heinlein
Never read those other books (Armor or, uh, the other one).

As for Snowcrash... Maybe. Depends on what you actually like. I didn't like it much, but a lot of people did.

I do really like Voice of the Whirlwind -- never actually managed to read Hardwired, although it's sitting on my shelf and I love me some Walter Jon (even if he was mean to me, that bastid. Okay, not really, he's a super nice guy).